Cartagena Dr, Toledo, Ohio
21 parcels on Cartagena Dr in Toledo, Lucas County, ZIP 43623. Mostly 1-family homes. Assessed values below come from the Lucas County Auditor's public record as of 2026-08-20.
- 21Parcels
- $439,900Median assessed value
- $347,700 to $541,900Value range
- 1982 to 1988Year built
- 1-family homePredominant use
Parcels on Cartagena Dr
| Address | Owner of record | Parcel number | Type | Assessed value | Built | Sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4926 Cartagena Dr | Urbanski Mary Kay & Jordan S | 79-60147 | 1-family home | $442,700 | 1988 | 3,370 |
| 4934 Cartagena Dr | Winovich Peter J III & Kristin M | 79-60151 | 1-family home | $502,500 | 1986 | 3,464 |
| 4935 Cartagena Dr | McCullough Sophia G | 79-60214 | 1-family home | $538,500 | 1983 | 3,642 |
| 4944 Cartagena Dr | Woolf Leighton S & Marcia D | 79-60154 | 1-family home | $541,900 | 1983 | 3,373 |
| 4945 Cartagena Dr | Caldwell Edward A & Barbara | 79-60211 | 1-family home | $370,000 | 1984 | 3,102 |
| 4954 Cartagena Dr | Wildman James & Amy | 79-60157 | 1-family home | $510,500 | 1983 | 3,160 |
| 4955 Cartagena Dr | Mistry Bhagwati A Successor Trustee | 79-60207 | 1-family home | $398,300 | 1982 | 3,195 |
| 4964 Cartagena Dr | Demas Alexander P Trustee | 79-60161 | 1-family home | $439,900 | 1983 | 3,058 |
| 4965 Cartagena Dr | Bishara Amira I Tr | 79-60204 | 1-family home | $377,800 | 1983 | 3,002 |
| 5005 Cartagena Dr | Gotberg Brian Axel | 79-60201 | 1-family home | $399,000 | 1983 | 3,250 |
| 5006 Cartagena Dr | Payden Jeffery P & Susan E | 79-60164 | 1-family home | $514,400 | 1983 | 3,256 |
| 5015 Cartagena Dr | Fisher Mary Ellen Trustee | 79-60197 | 1-family home | $429,700 | 1983 | 3,103 |
| 5016 Cartagena Dr | Fakouri Nasheed | 79-60167 | 1-family home | $500,000 | 1984 | 3,767 |
| 5025 Cartagena Dr | Bonfiglio Michael A & Dawn M Co-Trustees | 79-60194 | 1-family home | $347,700 | 1983 | 3,331 |
| 5026 Cartagena Dr | Curtis Rebecca D | 79-60171 | 1-family home | $395,800 | 1983 | 2,889 |
| 5035 Cartagena Dr | Shawaker Andrew G & Samantha D Trustees | 79-60191 | 1-family home | $464,600 | 1983 | 2,671 |
| 5036 Cartagena Dr | Kwait Gail S | 79-60174 | 1-family home | $394,500 | 1983 | 3,854 |
| 5045 Cartagena Dr | Zerner Richard E & Nancy L | 79-60187 | 1-family home | $378,400 | 1983 | 3,175 |
| 5046 Cartagena Dr | Dlr | 79-60177 | 1-family home | $441,300 | 1984 | 3,984 |
| 5055 Cartagena Dr | Thornton Justin & Adreanne | 79-60184 | 1-family home | $414,900 | 1985 | 2,893 |
| 5056 Cartagena Dr | Whitesel Zachariah M | 79-60181 | 1-family home | $474,700 | 1985 | 3,079 |
Search any Lucas County parcel
About these values
These are county-assessed values, not sale prices and not appraisals. Ohio taxable value is 35 percent of the assessed market value shown here. If a value on this street looks wrong, the county Board of Revision is where an owner can challenge it, free, by March 31: see how to file in Lucas County.
Owner names above are the owner of record on the county tax roll, printed in the roll's own order rather than rearranged. Tax status, sales and deed history, ownership timeline, and full building detail for each parcel are in the parcel record itself. Follow any address above.
Nearby in Toledo
- Cameron Ln
- Camille Dr
- Campbell St
- Canada Southern Ave
- Canal Ave
- Candlestick Ct
- Canfield Rd
- Cannons Park
- Canterbury Ct
- Canton Ave
- Capital Commons Dr
- Capri Dr
- Capshore Dr
- Caravelle Dr
- Carbon St
- Carlingfort Dr
- Carlton St
- Carlyle St
- Carmelle Ct
- Carnation Dr
- Carol Ln
- Caroline Ave
- Carriage Dr
- Carriage Hill Dr
- Carrie Pine Ln
- Carrietowne Ct
- Carrietowne Ln
- Carrington St
- Carroll Pl
- Carskaddon Ave
- Carthage Rd
- Carver Blvd
- Cason Ave
- Cass Rd
- Castle Ridge Rd
- Castlerock Dr
- Castleton Ave
- Castlewood Dr
- Caswell Ave
- Catalina Dr
- Catawba St
- Cavalear Dr
- Caxton Ln
- Cecelia Ave
- Cedar Creek Ln
- Cedarbrook Ln
- Cedardale Ct
- Cedarhurst Rd
- Celesta Dr
- Centennial Rd
- Central Ave
- Central Grove Ave
- Central Park
- Chadbury Ln
- Chadwick Dr
- Chalice Way
- Chalmette Dr
- Champe Rd
- Champion St
- Champlain St